1755 - 1833 Catalogue of Members
Congregational Church
East Haven, Connecticut
Try our genealogy search engine
Of the members of the Congregational Church in East Haven, from 1755, when Rev. Nicholas Street was ordained Pastor, to the present time, Dec., 1833.
N.B. The persons against whose names this mark * is inserted, are dead. The names of those who are dismissed or who have removed from this town with or without a dismission, are printed in Italics. The Names of those from whom the Church has withdrawn fellowship, are omitted as being blotted out. Their number is 14.
East Haven Congregational Church Members
- * Joshua Austin
- * Mehitabel, wife of Joshua Austin
- * Thomas Smith
- * Deodate Davenport
- * Lydia, wife of Deodate Davenport
- * Sarah Davenport
- * Esther, wife of Stephen Morris
- * John Russel
- * Mary, wife of John Russel
- * Mary, wife of David Smith
- * John Chedsey
- * Sarah, wife of John Chedsey
- * Mary, wife of Nathaniel Ludington
- * Sarah, wife of Samuel Bradley
- * Hannah, wife of Isaac Bradley
- * John Shepard
- * Sarah, wife of John Shepard
- * Eunice, wife of Thomas Smith
- * Theophilus Alling
- * Elizabeth, wife of Theophilus Alling
- * Caleb Bradley
- * Sarah, wife of Caleb Bradley
- * Sarah, wife of Dan Bradley
- * Abraham Chedsey
- * Bathsheba, wife of Abraham Chedsey
- * Daniel Hitchcock
- * Abigail, wife of Daniel Hitchcock
- * Daniel Bradley
- * Mehitabel, wife of Daniel Bradley
- * Thankful, wife of Stephen Bradley
- * Elizabeth, wife of Zebulon Bradley
- * Deborah, widow of Samuel Chedsey
- * Dan Moulthrop
- * Gideon Potter
- * Mary, wife of Gideon Potter
- * John Heminway
- * Mary, wife of John Heminway
- * Stephen Thompson
- * Hannah, wife of Stephen Thompson
- * Samuel Heminway
- * Sarah, wife of Abraham Heminway
- * Esther, wife of Timothy Thompson
- * Sarah, wife of Patterson Smith
- * Benjamin Smith
- * Desire, wife of Benjamin Smith
- * Rebekah, wife of Nathaniel Hitchcock, Jr.
- * Samuel Smith
- * Daniel Smith
- * Hannah, wife of Daniel Smith
- * Sarah, wife of George Pardee
- * Benjamin Pardee
- * Mary, wife of Benjamin Pardee
- * Sarah, wife of Isaac Pardee
- * Mary, wife of Jacob Pardee
- * Mary, wife of Stephen Pardee
- * Mary Pardee
- * Moses Thompson
- * Desire, wife of Moses Thompson
- * Abigail O'Neal
- * Lydia, widow of John Smith
- * Joseph Tuttle
- * Hannah, wife of John Rowe
- * Nathaniel Barnes
- * Mary, wife of Samuel Forbes
- * Thankful, wife of Isaac Howe
- * Elizabeth, wife of Samuel Thompson
- * Joseph Holt
- * Mercy, wife of Samuel Holt
- * Abigail, wife of Eliphalet Ludington
- * Anna, wife of Daniel Holt
- * Hannah, wife of Levi Bradley
- * Mehitabel, wife of Jesse Ludington
- * Mercy, wife of Eleazer Morris
- * John Moulthrop
- * Lydia, wife of Israel Moulthrop
- * Samuel Thompson
- * Hannah, wife of Samuel Thompson
- * Anna, wife of Asher Moulthrop
- * Mary, wife of Samuel Smith
- * Lydia Robinson
- * Sarah Robinson
- * Elizabeth, wife of Isaac Penfield
- * Caleb Chedsey
- * Abigail, wife of Caleb Chedsey
- * Hannah, wife of Thomas Dawson
- * Lydia Grannis
- * Matthew Moulthrop
- * Sarah, wife of Matthew Moulthrop
- * Hannah, wife of Samuel Chedsey, Jr.
- * Mehitabel, wife of Thomas Grannis
- * Isaac Chedsey
- * Sarah, wife of Isaac Chedsey
- * Joel Tuttle
- * Rebekah, wife of Joel Tuttle
- * Dorothy Tuttle
- * Margaret Jacobs
- * Mary, wife of John Higgins
- * Keziah, wife of Gideon Potter, Jr.
- * Elizabeth Woodward
- * Mercy Pardee
- * Deborah, wife of Titus Alling
- * Richard Darrow
- * Abigail, wife of Nathaniel Jocelin
- * Thankful, wife of Robert Dawson
- * Sarah, wife of Rev. Jacob Heminway
- * Mary, widow of Samuel Goodsell
- * Abigail, wife of Dan Goodsell
- * Lydia, wife of Ebenezer Darrow
- * Hannah, wife of Peter Woodward
- * Eunice, wife of Ebenezer Pardee
- * Sarah, wife of Timothy Russel
- * Esther, wife of Joseph Hotchkiss
- * Gideko and Abigail, blacks
The above names of members were collected and recorded by Rev. Mr. Street in 1756; Mr. Heminway having left no record.
1757
- Feb. 20. * Mabel, wife of Isaac Mallory
- Mar. 13. * Mary, wife of John Woodward
- Mar. 13. * Lorana Becket
- Mar. 27. * Mary, wife of John Dawson
- Mar. 27. * Abigail, wife of John Moulthrop
- July 3. * Abraham Heminway
- July 3. * Mercy, wife of Ab: Heminway
- July 3. * Zurviah, wife of Joshua Sperry
1758
- Sept. 21. * Catherine, servant of John Woodward
1759
- June 3. * John Davenport
- June 3. * Samuel Davenport
1761
- May 31. * Mehitabel, wife of Deacon Saml. Heminway
- Nov. 12. * Desire, wife of Rev. Nicholas Street
- Nov. 12. * Sarah, wife of John Denison
1762
- Sept. 19. * Elizabeth, wife of Samuel Shepard
- Sept. 19. * Mary, wife of Edward Russel, Jr.
1763
- Mar. 27. * Elizabeth, widow of Ebenezer Roberts
- May 29. * Isaac Chedsey, 2d.
- May 29. * Daniel Whedon
- Sept. 18. * Joshua Austin
- Sept. 18. * Abigail, wife of Joshua Austin
- Sept. 18. * Lydia Pardee
- Oct. 16. * Desire, wife of Samuel Thompson
1764
- July 15. * Amos Morris
- July 15. * Lydia, wife of Amos Morris
- July 21. * Simeon Bradley
- July 21. * Abigail, wife of Simeon Bradley
1765
- Feb. 24. * Mary Russel
- Feb. 24. * Mabel, widow of Doct. Utter.
- Feb. 24. * Mary Mallory, Jr.
- June 23. * Amy, wife of Abraham Bradley
1766
- Jan. 20. * Mary Mallory
- June 20. * Elizabeth, wife of Jacob Bradley
- Sept. 21. * John Heminway
- Oct. 21. * Phineas Curtis
- Nov. 21. * Sarah, wife of Ezra Fields
1767
- June 21. * Patterson Smith
- Oct. 25. * Jenny, a black woman
- Dec. 6. * Anna, wife of Thomas Smith
1768
- July 24. * Susannah, wife of Joshua Austin
1771
- Oct. 13. * Aaron Page
- Oct. 13. * Stephen Smith
1772
- June 28. * Ruth, wife of John Woodward, Jr.
1773
- Jan. 24. * Hannah, wife of Rev. N. Street
- Jan. 24. * Mary, wife of Gurdon Bradley
- Jan. 31. * Binah and Nanne, black women
- Aug. 15. * Samuel Holt
- Aug. 15. * Mary, wife of Samuel Holt
- Aug. 15. * Dan Holt
- Aug. 15. * Anna, wife of Dan Holt
- Sept. 19. * John Fuller
- Sept. 19. * Lydia, wife of John Fuller
- Sept. 19. * Comfort, wife of Josiah Bradley
- Sept. 19. * Jemima, wife of John Heminway
- Sept. 19. * Widow, Mary Richards
- Oct. 10. * Sarah, wife of Abijah Bradley
- Nov. 17. Elisha Andrews
- Nov. 17. Sarah, wife of Elisha Andrews
- Dec. 5. * Lydia, wife of Jacob Goodsell
- Dec. 19. * Stephen Tuttle
- Dec. 19. * Rhoda, wife of Stephen Tuttle
- Dec. 26. * Nathaniel Ludington
- Dec. 26. * Abigail, wife of John Barnes
1774
- Jan. 9. * Mary, wife of Ambrose Smith
- Mar. 27. * Hannah, wife of Levi Chedsey
- Apr. 17. * Joseph Russel
- Apr. 17. * Abigail, wife of Joseph Russel
- Apr. 17. * Sarah, wife of Isaac Chedsey, 2d.
- May 8. * Israel Potter
- May 8. * Mary, wife of Israel Potter
- May 8. * Hannah, wife of Joseph Holt
- May 8. * Mary, wife of Isaac Ludington
- May 8. * Jemima Pardee
- July 17. * Stephen Shepard
- July 17. * Amy, wife of Stephen Shepard
- July 17. * Thankful Moulthrop
In Sept. the congregation removed from the old house at the northwest corner of the green, into the new house, now occupied. Then the church was composed of about 140 members.
1775
- Mar. 5. * Joseph Mallory
- Mar. 5. * Eunice, wife of Joseph Mallory
- May 21. * Lydia, wife of Azariah Bradley
- Dec. 3. * Sibyl Denison
1776
- Mar. 3. * Timothy Bradley
- Mar. 3. * Sarah, wife of Timothy Bradley
1777
- Feb. 9. * Sarah, wife of Jared Bradley
- Aug. 10. * Mehitabel Russel
- Aug. 10. Mary, wife of David Grannis
- Aug. 10. Abigail, wife of John Goodsell
- Aug. 10. * Huldah, wife of Elias Townsend
- Dec. 21. * Mabel, wife of Stephen Pardee, Jr.
- Dec. 21. * Widow, Eunice Britin
1778
- Mar. 21. Amy, wife of Asa Bradley
- Apr. 5. * Samuel Smith, Jr.
- Apr. 5. Anna, wife of Samuel Smith, Jr.
- Apr. 5. * Widow, Sarah Scott
- Apr. 5. * Elizabeth, wife of David Eggleston
- Oct. 18. * Widow, Abigail Bishop
1779
- Jan. 31. * Widow, Rebekah Bradley
- Mar. 21. * Huldah, wife of Ezra Rowe
- Mar. 21. * Rachel, wife of Samuel Crumb
1780
- Feb. 27. * Amos Morris, Jr.
- Feb. 27. * Elizabeth, wife of Amos Morris, Jr.
- July 30. * Samuel Townsend
- July 30. * Levi Pardee
- July 30. * Stephen Smith, Jr.
- Aug. 6. * Eunice Street
1781
- Apr. 1. * Abraham Chedsey
- May 20. * Lydia, wife of Samuel Holt
- May 20. Abigail Hitchcock
- July 29. John Morris
- July 29. * Desire, wife of John Morris
- July 29. * James Adkins Broton
- Nov. 24. * Mehitabel, wife of Dan Bradley
- Nov. 24. * Hannah, wife of Isaac Forbes
1782
- Jan. 27. * Abigail, wife of James A. Broton
- Apr. 28. * Desire, wife of Moses Thompson
- Apr. 28. * Martha, wife of Moses Heminway
- Aug. 11. * Widow Lydia Goodsell
- Aug. 11. * Thankful, wife of Jesse Ludington, Jr.
- Dec. 22. * Lydia, wife of Isaac Hotchkiss
- Dec. 22. * Mary, wife of Amos Thompson
1783
- July 6. * Hannah, wife of Asa Mallory
- Aug. 20. * Sibyl, wife of Elihu Bradley
- Oct. 5. * Caleb Smith
- Oct. 5. * Daniel Tuttle
- Oct. 19. * Elizabeth, wife of Joseph Heminway
1784
- Feb. 22. * Esther, wife of John Rowe, Jr.
- Feb. 22. Temperance, wife of Joseph Hotchkiss
- Feb. 22. Lydia, wife of Edmund Bradley
- Mar. 21. * Abigail, wife of Nathaniel Barnes, Jr.
- Oct. 17. * Widow Lois Moulthrop
1785
- Feb. 3. * Widow Rachel Ludington
1787
- Jan. 25. * Hannah, wife of Samuel Heminway
- Feb. 8. * Lois, wife of Nehemiah Smith
- Apr. 22. * Leavit Pardee
- Apr. 22. * Elizabeth, wife of Leavit Pardee
- Apr. 22. Sarah, wife of Ira Smith
- May 5. Elizabeth, wife of Stephen Woodward
- May 5. * Martha, wife of Nathaniel Grannis
- May 5. * Stephen Rowe
- May 5. * Abigail, wife of Stephen Rowe
- May 20. * Abigail, wife of Joseph Heminway
- Sept. 2. Eunice, wife of Matthew Rowe
- Nov. 4. * Eunice, wife of Benjamin Mallory
1788
- June 1. Enos Heminway
- June 1. Sarah, wife of Enos Heminway
- June 1. * Susannah Roberts
- July 6. * Anna, wife of John Chedsey
- July 13. Sarah, wife of Levi Potter
- July 13. * Lois, wife of Joel Thompson
- July 13. Amy, wife of Daniel Tuttle
- Sept. 7. * Tabitha, wife of Philemon Augur
- Nov. 23. Widow Lucinda Hickox
1789
- May 24. * Abigail, wife of Amos Mallory
1790
- Aug. 15. * Abigail, wife of Christopher Tuttle
1791
- Aug. 28. * Lois, wife of Isaac Barnes
- Nov. 18. * Desire, wife of Ephraim Chedsey
1792
- Dec. 18. * Hannah, wife of Asaph Hotchkiss
1793
- Sept. 22. Elizabeth, wife of Andrew Davidson
- Sept. 22. Mehitabel, wife of Stephen Bradley, Jr.
- Sept. 22. * Hannah, wife of Jesse Mallory
- Sept. 22. * Lydia, wife of Solomon Barnes
- Dec. 8. * Huldah, wife of Joel Northrup
1794
- Oct. 12. * Reuben Moulthrop
- Oct. 12. Hannah, wife of Reuben Moulthrop
- Oct. 26. * Abijah Pardee
- Oct. 26. Rosanna, wife of Abijah Pardee
- Oct. 26. Sarah, wife of Joseph Pardee
1795
- Feb. 15. Mary, wife of John Woodward, Jr.
- Feb. 15. Martha, wife of Elam Potter
- Dec. 13. Allice, a black woman
1796
- Apr. 3. Roswell Davenport
- Apr. 3. Esther, wife of R. Davenport
- Apr. 3. Sarah, wife of Philemon Harrison
- Apr. 24. Desire, wife of Thomas Smith
- Apr. 24. * Rebekah, wife of Caleb Chedsey
- Apr. 24. * Sarah, wife of Samuel Thompson, Jr.
- July 10. Mary, wife of William Bradley
- Aug. 21. Dorcas, wife of John Thompson
1797
- Mar. 19. * Rachel, wife of David Moulthrop
- July 16. Sarah, wife of Daniel Austin
- Aug. 6. * Widow Sarah Thompson
1799
- May 6. * Esther, wife of Stephen Heminway
- May 26. * Lois, wife of Edward Russel
- June 30. Jacob Heminway
- June 30. Abigail, wife of Jacob Heminway
- Aug. 4. * Elizabeth, wife of John Shepard, Jr.
- Aug. 4. Lydia, wife of Ammi Bradley
- Aug. 18. Asenath, wife of Hezekiah Woodward
- Aug. 18. Elizabeth, wife of Amos Bradley
- Sept. 1. Sarah, wife of Caleb Smith
- Nov. 10. Widow, Lydia Smith
1800
- Apr. 24. * Hannah, wife of Abraham Chedsey
- May 25. Lorinda, wife of Heminway Holt
- May 25. Amy, wife of William Smith
- June 22. * John Tyler
- June 22. Mabel, wife of John Tyler
- June 22. Irene, wife of Nehemiah Smith
- June 22. * Eunice, wife of Timothy Thompson, Jr.
- June 22. * Widow, Lydia Bradley
- July 15. Lois, wife of Martin Rowland
1801
- Jan. 18. Anna, wife of Bela Farnham
- Mar. 1. Esther, wife of Elijah Bradley
- May 31. Lydia, wife of James Thompson
- Sept. 27. Amy Beach
1802
- Feb. 4. * Mary, wife of Philemon Augur
- Feb. 4. Mary Frost
- Feb. 4. * Hannah, wife of John Heminway
- Feb. 21. Hannah, wife of Ephraim Chedsey
- Feb. 21. * Anna, wife of Levi Baldwin
- Feb. 21. * Hannah, wife of Abraham Farren
1803
- July 24. Amy, wife of Joseph Holt, Jr.
1804
- Jan. 29. Hezekiah Davenport
- Aug. 16. * Samuel Shepard
- Oct. 7. Lois, wife of Horatio G. Street
- Oct. 7. Desire, wife of Philemon Holt
- Oct. 28. Mary, wife of Abraham Thompson
1805
- Mar. 7. * Nehemiah Smith
- Mar. 7. * Justin W. Street
- July 21. Dorcas Way
1806
- Jan. 5. * Sarah, wife of Levi Pardee
- Jan. 5. * Ruth Bishop
- Jan. 5. Lydia, wife of Jacob Farren
- Jan. 5. * Sarah, wife of Isaac Brown
- Jan. 5. * Mehitabel, wife of James Chedsey
- Jan. 5. * Widow Mary Chedsey
- Jan. 5. Widow Abigail Andrews
- Jan. 5. * Mary, wife of Isaac Bradley
- Jan. 5. * Lovice, wife of Joel Bradley
- Jan. 5. Betsey, wife of Samuel Chedsey
- Jan. 5. Jane F., wife of Samuel Lindsley
Persons received after Mr. Street's death
- Jan. 5. * Didamea, wife of Samuel Smith
- Jan. 5. Mary Street
- Jan. 5. Harriet Morris
- Jan. 5. Lucy Morris
- Jan. 5. Anna Woodward
Persons received at different times, by letter, from other churches, and not before recorded
1807
- Mar. 5. * Mehitabel Augur
- Mar. 5. * Phebe, wife of William Everton
- Mar. 5. * Eunice, wife of Moses Heminway
- Mar. 5. * Hannah Pardee
- Mar. 5. * Phebe, wife of Gurdon Pardee
- May 7. * Eunice, wife of Daniel Bradley
- May 7. * Lois, wife of Silas Bishop
- Apr. 30. * Widow Hannah Brown
- Apr. 30. Elizabeth, wife of Amasa Forbes
1808
- Mar. 5. Elijah Rowe, and Mary, his wife, by letter
- Mar. 5. Phebe, wife of John Davenport, by letter
- July 3. * Benjamin Mallory
- July 3. * Joseph Hotchkiss
- July 3. Isaac Bradley, Jr.
- July 3. Sarah, wife of Isaac Ludington
- July 3. Sarah, wife of Isaac H. Pardee
- July 3. Lois, wife of Edward R. Smith
- July 3. Elizabeth, wife of Heman Hotchkiss
- July 3. Mary Dawson
- July 3. * Mary Barnes
- July 3. Lydia Morris
- July 3. Polly Bradley
- July 3. Amy Bradley
- July 3. * Sarah Bradley
- July 3. Wealthy Bradley
- July 3. Abigail Holt
- July 3. * Nancy Shepard
- July 3. Elizabeth Augur
- July 3. Orilla Hotchkiss
- July 3. * Mary Hotchkiss
- July 3. * Hannah Goodsell
- July 3. * Eunice Pardee
- July 3. Mary Frost, Jr.
- Sept. 4. * Amy, wife of John Shepard
- Sept. 4. Ezra Rowe
- Sept. 4. * Hannah, wife of Jacob Mallory
- Sept. 4. * Asahel Bradley
- Sept. 4. Bela Farnham
- Sept. 4. William Woodward
- Sept. 4. Ezra Rowe, Jr.
- Sept. 4. Betsey, wife of Ezra Rowe, Jr.
- Sept. 4. Harvey Rowe
- Sept. 4. Jacob Barnes
- Sept. 4. Willet Heminway
- Sept. 4. Clarissa, wife of Elnathan Street
- Sept. 4. Sibyl, wife of Lyman Hotchkiss
- Sept. 4. * Desire Bradley
- Sept. 4. Phila Brown
- Sept. 4. Clarissa Brown
- Sept. 4. Nancy Davidson
- Sept. 4. Adah Bradley
- Sept. 4. * Mary Pardee
- Sept. 4. Sylvia Allen
- Sept. 4. Susan Bradley
- Nov. 6. John Rowe
- Nov. 6. Nicholas Street
- Nov. 6. Betsey, wife of Nicholas Street
- Nov. 6. * James Heminway
- Nov. 6. Elizabeth, wife of James Heminway
- Nov. 6. Levi Rowe
- Nov. 6. Eunice, wife of Levi Rowe
- Nov. 6. Daniel Smith
- Nov. 6. Irene Goodsell
- Nov. 6. Patty Mallory
- Nov. 6. Mary Brown
1809
- Jan. 1. Elizabeth, wife of Truman Russel
- Jan. 1. Lydia, wife of James Bradley
- Jan. 1. Asenath, wife of Asahel Bradley, 2d.
- Jan. 1. Nancy, wife of Justin W. Street
- Jan. 1. Betsey Heminway
- Jan. 1. Sarah Pardee
- Jan. 1. Eunice Miner
- Jan. 1. Harvey Heminway
- Jan. 1. Eben Tyler Heminway
- Jan. 1. Wyllys Heminway
- Mar. 5. * Mary, wife of Asher Moulthrop
- Mar. 5. * Huldah, wife of Amos Ludington
- Mar. 5. Mehitabel, wife of Russel Lanfear
- Mar. 5. Mehitabel, wife of Nathan Andrews
- Mar. 5. Gurdon Pardee
- Mar. 5. Abraham Thompson
- Mar. 5. * Isaac H. Pardee
- Mar. 5. Daniel Rowe
- Mar. 5. Elizabeth, wife of Daniel Rowe
- May 7. * Asa Mallory
- May 7. Timothy Thompson
- May 7. * Abigail Baldwin
- May 7. * Charlotte, wife of Amos Morris, Jr.
- May 7. Lois Smith
- July 2. Elizabeth, wife of Caleb Smith, 2d.
- July 2. * Widow Sarah Davidson
- Sept. 3. Mary, wife of George Landcraft
- Sept. 3. * Mary, wife of Roswell Bradley
- Sept. 3. Widow Amy Bradley
- Sept. 3. Eliza Andrews
- Sept. 3. * Huldah Ludington
- Nov. 5. Peggy Kism, a black woman
1810
- May 20. Sophia, wife of Jacob Goodsell, by letter
- Nov. 4. * Widow Mary Thompson
- Nov. 4. * Widow Sarah Landcraft
1811
- Sept. 11. Widow Lornhamah Goodsell, by letter
1812
- May 11. Widow Abigail Goodsell
- July 5. Sarah, wife of DeGrasse Maltby
1813
- Jan. 3. Grace, wife of Anson Bradley
- May 3. Elizabeth, wife of Elias Bradley
- Oct. 31. Elizabeth, wife of Samuel Bradley, 2d.
1814
- May 1. Widow Mary Thompson
1816
- Mar. 3. * Jacob Goodsell
- Mar. 3. Benjamin Pardee
- Mar. 3. Thomas Landcraft
- Mar. 3. * Lois, wife of Thomas Landcraft
- Mar. 3. * Lovice, wife of Roswell Augur
- Mar. 3. * Betsey, wife of John Farren
- Mar. 3. * Sarah, wife of John Larkins
- Mar. 3. * Lydia, wife of Isaac Moulthrop
- Mar. 3. Mary Larkins
- Mar. 3. Polly Bradley
- Mar. 3. Hannah Bradley
- Mar. 3. Nancy Thompson
- Mar. 3. Laura Chedsey
- Mar. 3. Eliza Chedsey
- Mar. 3. Statira Rowe
- Mar. 3. * Anson Todd
- May 5. * Anna, wife of Samuel Holt, by letter from the church in Bethlem.
- July 7. Roswell Augur
1817
- May 4. * Widow Elizabeth Smith
1818
- May 1. Abigail Ann, wife of Rev. S. Dodd, by letter from the church in Meredith, N. York.
- May 3. Rachel, wife of Daniel Hughes, by letter from the church in Bristol.
1819
- Oct. 31. * Jared Bradley
1820
- Mar. 5. Widow Lydia Potter
- Oct. 8. James R. Hunt
- Apr. 29. Levi Potter
- Apr. 29. Lucy, wife of Caleb C. Ludington
- Apr. 29. Eve Ely, wife of John Tyler, Jr.
- Apr. 29. Fanny, wife of Matthew Rowe
- Apr. 29. Samuel Russel Moulthrop
- Apr. 29. Daniel Moulthrop
- Apr. 29. * Roswell Rowe
- July 22. Lyman Hotchkiss
- July 22. Sarah, wife of Willet Heminway
- July 22. Lucy, wife of Joseph Grannis
- July 22. Nancy, wife of Hezekiah Shepard
- July 22. Widow Mary Tuttle
- July 22. Mehitabel Barnes
- July 22. Abigail Russel
- July 22. Sarah Landcraft
- July 22. Maria Landcraft
- Sept. 16. George Landcraft
- Sept. 16. Jacob Mallory
- Sept. 16. Jesse Mallory, 2d
- Sept. 16. Wealthy, wife of Jesse Mallory, 2d
- Sept. 16. John Larkins
- Sept. 16. Matthew Rowe
- Sept. 16. * Jesse Mallory
- Sept. 16. James Mallory
- Sept. 16. Maria Pardee
- Sept. 16. Almena Ludington
- Nov. 4. Wyllys Mallory
- Nov. 4. Huldah Hotchkiss
- Jan. 6. Sarah Holt
- Feb. 10. Elnathan Street
- Feb. 10. Dana Bradley
- Feb. 10. Mehitabel, wife of Dana Bradley
- Nov. 3. Loly, wife of Aner Pardee
1824
- Nov. 7. Sarah Chedsey, by letter from the church in Woodbury
1825
- Mar. 24. Harriet Ludington, by letter from the first church in Camillus, N. Y.
- Apr. 10. * Sarah Maria Forbes
- Sept. 4. Mary M., wife of J. H. B. Chedsey, by letter from the church in Guilford.
1826
- Mar. 5. Almira Smith
1827
- Mar. 4. Maria Moulthrop
- Mar. 4. Betsey M. Bradley
- June 3. Hannah, wife of Amaziah Landcraft
1828
- May 4. Lydia, wife of Gurdon Pardee, from the church in Prospect
- June 8. Dan Parmele, and Frances, his wife, from the church in Guilford, and
- Samuel H. Heminway, from the same church.
- July 1. Lois, wife of William Bradley, Jr.
- July 1. Mary, wife of Daniel Smith
- July 1. Jared Chedsey
- July 1. Lucretia Chedsey
- Nov. 2. Clarissa E. Pardee
1829
- Mar. 1. Amanda, wife of William Landcraft, by letter from the church in North Haven
1830
- Jan. 3. Cynthia, wife of Amos Bradley, Jr., by letter from the Presbyterian church in Herkimer, N. Y.
1831
- May 1. Samuel Bradley, 2d.
- May 1. Amos Bradley, Jr.
- May 1. Emeline Farnham
- May 1. Lorinda A. Holt
- May 1. Jane Adeline Bradley
- May 1. Frances Ann Street
- July 3. Ruel Andrews
- July 3. Olive, wife of Ruel Andrews
- July 3. Betsey Pardee Andrews
- July 3. Saltrue Andrews
- July 3. Betsey Woodward Street
- July 3. Harriet Jennet Street
- July 3. Stephen Woodward Bradley
- July 3. John H. B. Chedsey
- July 3. Thomas Grannis
- July 3. Almira, wife of Thomas Grannis
- July 3. Lucy, wife of Elihu Ives
- July 3. Joseph H. Rogers
- July 3. Nancy, wife of Lucius Nichols, by letter from the south church in Hartford
- Aug. 28. Isaac Pardee
- Aug. 28. Amos Morris
- Aug. 28. James Farren
- Aug. 28. Polly, wife of James Farren
- Aug. 28. Jeremiah Woodward
- Aug. 28. Mary, wife of J. Woodward
- Aug. 28. Widow Anna Pardee
- Aug. 28. Lois, wife of Zebulon Bradley
- Aug. 28. Sarah, wife of John Heminway
- Aug. 28. Amanda, wife of Samuel H. Heminway
- Aug. 28. Sarah, wife of Selah Upson
- Aug. 28. Levi Bradley
- Aug. 28. Mary, wife of Levi Bradley
- Aug. 28. Desire Smith, wife of John Farren, 2d.
- Aug. 28. Mary Ann, wife of Willet Bradley
- Aug. 28. Mary Ann, wife of Jeremiah Barnes
- Aug. 28. Eunice Pardee
- Aug. 28. Adeline Bradley
- Aug. 28. Julia Amanda Thompson
- Aug. 28. Julius Upson
- Aug. 28. Samuel Thompson
- Aug. 28. Maria Ann Bradley
- Aug. 28. Jerusha Louisa Tyler
- Aug. 28. Amoret Beach
- Aug. 28. Mary Angeline Bradley
- Aug. 28. Huldah Hughes Bradley
- Aug. 28. Grace Ann Hotchkiss
- Aug. 28. Charlotte Emily Holt
- Aug. 28. Lydia Holt
- Aug. 28. Almira Grannis
- Aug. 28. Sarah Heminway
- Aug. 28. Charlotte Bradley
- Aug. 28. Susan Andrews
- Aug. 28. Anna Chedsey
- Aug. 28. Almira Chedsey
- Aug. 28. Charles Woodward
- Aug. 28. Charlotte Delight Todd
- Aug. 28. Lucy Morris Street
- Aug. 28. Harriet Andrews
- Aug. 28. Ruth Curtis Woodward
- Aug. 28. Asenath Woodward, Jr.
- Dec. 11. Stephen Smith, 2d.
- Dec. 11. Betsy, wife of Stephen Smith, 2d. and Maryette, their daughter
- Dec. 11. Grace Goodsell
- Dec. 11. Elizabeth Morris Bradley
1832
- July 1. * Amanda, wife of Elias Bishop
- Sept. 30. John Heminway
1833
- Nov. 10. Almira Farren
The number of members in the year 1756, when Mr. Street collected and recorded the names, 114
From 1756 to Oct. 1806, the end of Mr. Street's ministry, were added, 230
Received after Mr. Street's death, and at various times from other churches, 14
Admitted by Mr. Clark, 118
Admitted by Mr. Dodd, 125
Total, 601
Number of deaths and removals since 1756, 441
Number of members that remain, 160