New Horizons Genealogy
"Specializing in New England and New York Colonial American Ancestry"


Ashtabula Ohio Biographies and Biographical Sketches of Early Settlers and Prominent Families

Transcribed by Jeffrey Tooley


Try our genealogy search engine


Ashtabula Ohio Biographies and Biographical Sketches of Early Settlers and Prominent Families, extracted from History of New Haven County, Ohio, Volume II, by Rockey, J. L. (John L.) cn, 1892, and

Verification status: This dataset is a secondary source document manually transcribed and verified by Jeffrey Tooley, and contains 100% human-verified and manually audited historical transcriptions, completely free of automated OCR or AI hallucinations.


Philo Booth Biographical Sketch

Philo Booth was the son of Lemuel Booth and Mehetabel Morse, his wife, and was born at Huntington, Connecticut, August 11, 1780. Was apprenticed to a druggist of Troy, New York, named Hyde. Afterwards, while a clerk in the store of Abraham Cooper, at Trenton, Oneida county, New York, he married Sophia Cooper, a sister of his employer, August 22, 1805. He afterwards engaged in merchandising at Rodman, in Jefferson county, New York, and in the fall of 1813, as soon as Perry’s victory on Lake Erie had freed the west from all danger of hostile Indians, he started with his family and goods for Cleveland, Ohio, expecting to transport his goods in boats from Buffalo to Cleveland.

On arriving at Buffalo he found that all of the boats and shipping on the lake had been taken by the government, for the purpose of bringing General Harrison’s army down the lake, and the road west from Buffalo was almost impassable, having been badly cut up by the transportation of military stores. Leaving most of his goods in Buffalo, he employed two teams to transport his family and some light goods, and in nine days arrived at Erie, Pennsylvania, where he remained over two months. In the mean time the British took Buffalo and burnt it, and he lost all the goods that he had left there. He was at Erie when General Harrison arrived there from the west, and the town being crowded with soldiers and sailors, he started again, with his family and what property he had, in wagons, and arrived at Ashtabula, January 15, 1814, and being detained there by the birth of a son, and having no merchandise to sell, he concluded to settle there.

His father and mother were with him, and as his father was a tanner, he at once started a tannery on the west side of Ashtabula creek, and continued in that business for about fifteen years. In the fall of 1827 he commenced merchandising in company with his son-in-law, Charles Crosby, and continued in the business for many years, generally in company with one of his sons.

He was one of the most enterprising, honorable, and public-spirited business men of the town, and did his full share in building up the village, which is now so prosperous. He died at Ashtabula, June 27, 1852. His widow, born September 17, 1785, died September 3, 1861.

They lost in infancy three sons and reared a family of two sons and six daughters, all of whom, excepting the oldest and youngest daughters, have remained at Ashtabula, viz.

Cordelia C., born at Western, Oneida county, New York, September 29, 1807; married November 16, 1825, to Charles Crosby; both now living at Chicago, Illinois.

John, born at Rodman, July 26, 1809; married Mary Ann Fuller, May 9, 1836, who died July 13, 1856. He still lives at Ashtabula.

Laura, born at Rodman, October 24, 1811; married, November 18, 1829, to Stephen H. Farrington, M.D., who died March 8, 1875, at Ashtabula, where she still resides.

Charles, born January 15, 1814, at Ashtabula, where he still resides.

Sophia, born March 4, 1816, at Ashtabula; married, June 10, 1841, to Ezekiel C. Root, a merchant, who died, May 8, 1861, at Ashtabula; and she died there, May 10, 1875.

Caroline, born June 22, 1822, at Ashtabula, where she still lives.

Catherine, born at Ashtabula, January 26, 1825; married, November 10, 1846, to Stephen B. Wells. They still live at Ashtabula.

Harriet, born at Ashtabula, January 3, 1828; married, March 16, 1849, to Augustus Henry Griswold; both now living at Oakland, California.

His father died at Ashtabula, May 5, 1825, aged seventy-six; and his mother died at Ashtabula, August 4, 1838, aged eighty-five.


Amasa Castle, Jr., Biographical Sketch

Amasa Castle, Jr., was born in Plymouth, Connecticut, April 5, 1786, from which place his parents removed to Burlington, Vermont, where they remained several years, finally emigrating in 1808 to “New Connecticut,” and halting in Ashtabula, at that date a dense forest teeming with Indians, wolves, bears, and other wild animals.

His father, Amasa Castle, Sr., was a brave, intrepid soldier in the War of the Revolution, and brought to the new home all the spirit and energy which characterized the men of that generation, and helped them to conquer the apparently insurmountable obstacles which beset the frontiersman's progress. The mother, Mrs. Mary Stanley Castle, who was a direct descendant of the English Stanleys, was a woman of rare abilities and great strength of character, a worthy mother of children who helped to make the history of this country. Her father and eldest brother were made prisoners of war by the British, and, with hundreds of others, were poisoned while confined on a prison-ship at Baltimore. Afterwards a monument, in or near New York, bearing their names, and which still exists, was raised to their memory. Another brother, Frederic Stanley, Esq., afterwards a distinguished lawyer of New York, was, when only nineteen, one of General Washington's aides-de-camp, and on numerous occasions distinguished himself by his fearless heroism and devotion to the cause for which they were fighting.

With the inheritance of such qualities as these, combined with inflexible rectitude of principle, Mr. Castle brought to the wilderness only his strong arms, light heart, and perfect health. Buying some land on the “South Ridge,” about a mile east of where the village stands, he, with his father, and brother Daniel, commenced the task of making a productive farm in the midst of the unbroken forest. Like all the pioneers of that time, they suffered great hardships, often lacking necessary food, and being compelled to depend on wood-craft to keep from starvation. Even after the grain was raised it was difficult to get it ground, the nearest mill being at Cleveland or Walnut Creek, sixty miles away, and no mode of conveyance except the horse’s back. This, with the dangers from wild animals which beset the journey, made it a great undertaking, and often their only bread was made from corn pounded in a wooden mortar. In these days of steam-mills, railroads, and other things, which seem a common and necessary part of our civilization, it seems almost incredible that people should voluntarily endure such privations, and the present generation is too apt to forget how much of its present prosperity is owing to the courage and perseverance of its ancestors.

During the War of 1812, Mr. Castle was one of the militia so often called out to protect the government stores at Cleveland and at Ashtabula Harbor from being captured by the British. So continual were the alarms, so great the anxiety, and so determined the patriotism of the hardy settlers, that scarcely enough persons were left at home to raise the necessary food for sustenance, and nearly all the work was done by the women and children, aided by a few men unfit for military duty. During all that time of trial and suffering no one was ever more ready and willing for service, however hard and dangerous, than the subject of this sketch.

In January, 1813, he married Miss Rosalinda Watrous (their marriage license standing third on the records of Ashtabula County), daughter of Captain John Watrous, who emigrated from Saybrook, Connecticut, in the year 1810, with two yoke of oxen and one horse, the journey occupying forty days. With Captain Watrous were his wife and ten children, some of them already men and women, Rosalinda being at the time but fourteen years old.

Arrived in Ashtabula, they first settled at the Harbor, with every prospect of prosperity; but a heavy sorrow was in store for them, for only four brief weeks had elapsed when the father suddenly sickened and died, leaving this stricken family, homesick and almost discouraged, to struggle with the hardships of the new country. Captain Watrous was the third white man buried in West Ashtabula.

Mr. and Mrs. Castle raised a family of six children, two of whom, with their mother, still reside in Ashtabula. For fifty-eight years they walked hand-in-hand through the path of life, sometimes in sunshine and sometimes in shadow, but always in perfect harmony; and when at last, in December, 1870, at the age of eighty-four, he lay down to his final rest, his devoted wife received his last word and look of recognition. By their industry and self-denial they not only educated their children, but acquired a competency which rendered comfortable their declining years; but the best inheritance of their children will be the example of their lives of energy, content, and spotless integrity.


David Edward Kelley, D.D.B., Biographical Sketch

David Edward Kelley, D.D.B. This gentleman, who is a citizen of Ashtabula, and who is regarded as a rising young man in the field of dentistry, is a native of this county, the son of David H. Kelley, Esq., of Saybrook township. May 8, 1853, is the date of his birth. His education was obtained at the district schools of his native township and at Grand River institute, Austinburg. His professional education was obtained at the Philadelphia Dental college, Philadelphia, receiving from that institution his graduating diploma, February 27, 1875. In 1875, November 11, he was united in marriage with Nellie Roy Moore, daughter of M. M. and Helen Moore, Erie, Pennsylvania. Mr. and Mrs. Kelley are the parents of one child, Edward Raymond Kelley, born September 1, 1876. Mr. Kelley is a gentleman of unblemished character, is attentive to his business, skillful in dentistry, studious of his profession, ambitious to attain the highest standard, and is highly esteemed by his professional brethren.


John Porteous Robertson Biographical Sketch

John Porteous Robertson. This gentleman is the oldest of eleven, the children of John and Margaret Robertson, the former of whom was a native of Jedburgh, Scotland, and the latter of Cambridge, New York, from which point they removed to Ripley, Chautauqua county, New York, in 1827. and from there to Ashtabula in 1847. Here they died, the father in 1851, and the mother three years later. The subject of this sketch was born in Cambridge, New York, October 3, 1807. The opportunities afforded him for an education were limited, consisting of from four to six months per year at the district school, until he had arrived at the age of twelve years. His ambition was to acquire an education and fit himself for teaching; but his father’s means being limited, and a large family to support, he was taken into the blacksmith-shop with his father and remained there till of age. With the one purpose still in view, he saved every sixpence. He had hoarded enough to purchase a set of school-books, and every spare hour was from this time on employed in “ digging out” the hard problems of old Pike and mastering Murray, which was done without a teacher. Thus, by dint of hard study, he was, on attaining his majority, a fair English scholar.

From 1828 to 1834 his time was occupied principally in teaching. In 1835 he began his mercantile career in Rockville, Crawford county, Pennsylvania, with a capital of less than one thousand dollars; came to Ashtabula in 1838, and has remained there, the greater part of the time engaged in trade, until this time. The crash of 1837 found him in Pittsburgh with a fleet of ten boats or arks loaded with lumber. This was landed two days after the suspension of the banks. He lost two thousand dollars by this venture; came home, closed up business, paying every indebtedness in full, and with the one thousand dollars saved from the wreck came to Ashtabula and entered into a copartnership with J. I. Post & Co. Since 1841, with the exception of three years, he has “sailed his own ship.” During his long and busy life, Mr. Robertson has filled many official positions, beginning, in 1836, by an appointment as justice of the peace by the governor of Pennsylvania. Has been mayor of Ashtabula one year; eight years member of council; six years township trustee; seven years treasurer of township; five years treasurer of borough; and six years treasurer and member of board of education. Mr. Robertson was on January 26, 1S36, united in marriage to Miss Lovenia, daughter of John and Susannah Seiple, of Rockville, Crawford county, New York. From this union seven children have been born, three of whom are boys and unmarried. The eldest daughter, Mary, married James II. Prentice, and resides in Saginaw, Michigan; Margaret, the next daughter, married G. C. Mygall, of Ashtabula; Alice is unmarried; Caroline married George W. Kepler, who perished in the Ashtabula disaster, December 29, 1876. He was at the time of his death proprietor of the Erie store, a young man of splendid business talent, and highly esteemed by his associates. His remains were never found. His widow still carries on the business, under the name of Kepler & Co.

Politically, Mr. Robertson began life as an old-line Whig, and is now a Republican, stanch and true.

His religious belief is Calvinistic. Having been trained in the Scotch Presbyterian church, he early embraced its faith, and is now an elder of that church. His life has been a busy one, and he has now the satisfaction of knowing that he has ever met his obligations, has done his share towards supporting church and state, to assist the needy, and to benefit his fellow-man.


Hall Smith Biographical Sketch

Hall Smith. The subject of this sketch was born in New Marlborough, Berkshire county, Massachusetts, in the summer of 1775. At this time his father, John Smith, was absent, a soldier of the Revolutionary army. His mother died when he was but seven days old, and he fell under the care of his maternal grandparents, Ebenezer and Anna Hall, by whom he was nurtured and raised, along with a son of their own, but a few days older than himself. At the age of thirteen he was apprenticed to an uncle, Moses Hall, to learn the clothier’s trade. At the close of his apprenticeship, he found himself disqualified for book-keeping in consequence of an accident. He Studied under the Rev. Jacob Catlin with that intense application which was his constitutional propensity. Early in the present century he, by assistance, procured blankets and other goods, and came to the wilds of northern Ohio. These were exchanged with the Indians of Sandusky and the white settlers in the wilderness of New Connecticut for furs. This traffic he continued for several years, and about the year 1806 opened a store at Austinburg, the first store in Ashtabula County. About 1807 he married Julia Anna, eldest daughter of the Rev. Jas. Badger, a very excellent woman, by whom he had one son, who died in infancy. In 1809 his wife also died. The year after her death he purchased lands and opened a store in Ashtabula, and here entered into business quite extensively, supplying the settlers with what was necessary to the clearing up and improving of a new country. He was liberal in contributing towards all public benefits in the county. The poor always found in him a benefactor. In 1811 he was again married, to Achsah, daughter of Roger Nettleton, of Kingsville, by whom he had three daughters and one son. In 1812, Mr. Smith entered into partnership with Nathan Strong, and built the grist, and saw-mills which so many years occupied the site of the stone mills now owned by Messrs. Fisk and Sillman. In 1815, Mr. Smith, together with those other public benefactors of that day, Matthew Hubbard, Amos Fisk, and Philo Booth, erected a building for religious and other public meetings, which, though not formally yet in fact was donated to the public. The upper part of this building was for many years used for a Masonic hall. This was afterwards removed and fitted up for an academy, and was afterwards again removed and occupied for a fireman’s hall. Mr. Smith, having been educated a Congregationalist, although not a member of that body, was their first and for many years their principal supporter in Ashtabula. The village of Ashtabula is indebted to the liberality of Mr. Smith for the North public square and the cemetery adjoining it, and for many other public benefits. About the year 1813 he became a Mason, remained in good standing in that order while his reason lasted, and his body was attended to the place of burial January 15, 1857, by the members of Rising Sun lodge, No. 22, and was interred with the impressive ceremonies of the brotherhood. For many of the later years of his life the once brilliant mind of Mr. Smith was under a mental cloud, which continued until his death.


Lewis Smith Biographical Sketch

Lewis Smith. The parents of this gentleman were James Smith, who was born in Clinton, Oneida county, New York, and Laura Scoville Smith, of Saratoga county, same State. They came to Ohio in 1818, locating in Ashtabula and erecting a gristand saw-mill. These mills being among the first on the Reserve, were widely known, and patronage was drawn from a circuit of many miles. It was in this grist-mill, in January, 1831, that the father, while freeing the wheel from ice, was so severely injured that he died from its effects within an hour. He left considerable property, the bulk of which was, however, absorbed in settlement. The mother survived him many years; died November 14, 1875. Lewis W. Smith was born in Ashtabula on the 23d day of September, 1825, and is the third of a family of children, three sons aud two daughters. He was educated at district school and Ashtabula academy. Prior to 1851 he was a farmer. At this date he went to Cincinnati, Ohio, and engaged in the retail millinery business for one year; then removed to New York and entered into the importing and jobbing of silks, millinery, and straw goods. Continued there until 1873, when he returned to his native place, and with his son founded the now widely-known Ashtabula store. On January 6, 1849, he was, by the Rev. James Lowe, of the Methodist Episcopal church of Cleveland, Ohio, united in marriage to Mary Ann Gillmore, of that city, she being the daughter of Rev. James and Clarissa Gillmore. The fruit of the union is James Lewis Smith, who was born March 7, 1850, at Ashtabula, Ohio, and is, as stated above, a partner with his father. Mr. Smith is one of the substantial men of Ashtabula, and is largely identified with the city’s interests, being proprietor of several of the best business blocks of the place.


John B. Watrous, Captain, Biographical Sketch

Captain John B. Watrous second son of John and Roxanna Watrous, was born at Saybrook, Connecticut, January 15, 1700. When seventeen years of age, he made the journey to Ashtabula, Ohio, on horseback, and bought the farm on which he afterwards resided, now known as “Maple Grove.” He returned to Connecticut, and remained there until 1810, when, with his parents and family, he removed permanently to his wilderness home. The journey was performed by means of ox-teams, two yoke of oxen to each wagon. A log dwelling was soon erected, which quickly became a centre of graceful hospitalities to a large circle of genial friends. John B. was a soldier in the War of 1812, as were also two of his brothers. He was a prominent member of the Masonic fraternity, one of the first workers for the establishment of an Episcopal church in Ashtabula, and a director in the “Warren and Ashtabula Turnpike Company,” then considered a road of great importance to the country. His tastes were literary, and to a polished exterior he added the graces of a Christian character. His was a nature dispensing sunshine wherever he moved. Married at thirty-three years of age to a beautiful woman much his junior, he was a tender husband and judicious parent. He died in ripe old age, February 24, 1869. His wife, Julia Montgomery, was born in Conneaut, December 14, 1806. She was the youngest daughter of James Montgomery (who was the son of Robert Montgomery), and was born in Schoharie, New York. Robert Montgomery had emigrated from the north of Ireland, had been a soldier of the Revolution, and was a cousin-german of the Robert Montgomery who fell at Quebec.

James Montgomery had married Mary Raldwin, of Catskill, New York. The pair became pioneers of Conneaut, Ashtabula County, having removed there three years after the first settlement of Harpersfield. The journey from Buffalo was made in open boats, the intervening country being but a trackless forest. The parents and their four children disembarked at night, sleeping on the beach beneath their sheltering boats. Arrived at Conneaut, a dwelling was hastily constructed from the barks of trees, until a more substantial one of logs could be made; and this speedily became “a tavern,” for the accommodation of people emigrating still farther towards the setting sun.

The husband followed the business of boating between Conneaut and Erie, thus supplying the infant colony with provisions and other necessaries of life. He served for a time in the War of 1812, and later served for two successive terms in the legislature at Chillicothe, then the seat of government for the State.

Four more children were born to them in Conneaut, and when Julia was four years of age the Watrous family, then on their way to Ashtabula, stayed overnight at this inn, and then and there began the acquaintance which culminated in the marriage of John B. Watrous and Julia Montgomery on the 23d of June, 1823.

James Montgomery removed to Austinburg in 1813, and here soon after was born his son, Colonel James Montgomery, of Kansas celebrity, the famed “guerrilla chieftain,” the “fighting preacher.”Colonel Montgomery also commanded the Union army in Florida during the “late unpleasantness.” He died at Mound City, Kansas, in 1872.

James Montgomery, Sr., died at Ashtabula in 1834, and Mrs. Julia Montgomery Watrous is now the sole survivor of her father’s family.


George Willard Biographical Sketch

George Willard was born in Holland patent, New York, on the 12th day of August, 1812, and is the fifth of a family of twelve children born to Simon and Rhoda Wills Willard, originally of Weathersfield, Connecticut, but who removed in 1804 to Holland patent, where they remained until 1834, at which date they came to Ashtabula township. There the parents died, the mother January 21, 1842, and the father November 18, 1850. Of the brothers and sisters of George Willard, all are dead except one, the oldest brother, William, who is still a resident of Ashtabula. The education of Mr. Willard was acquired through the medium of our American system of common schools, after the completion of which he began what has proved to be the occupation of his life, that of merchandising, making his debut, in 1828, as clerk in a general store and forwarding and commission house, at Whitestown, Oneida county, New York. The Erie canal was then in its palmiest days. Remained here, engaged in this avocation, until 1831, when he came to Ashtabula, Ohio, and for the succeeding five years was clerk in the post-office and store of A. C. Hubbard. In April, 1836, Mr. Willard associated himself with Richard Roberts, and, under the firm-name of Roberts & Willard, opened, in the north half of the double two-story brick block built by H. J. Rees, a stock of goods, consisting of drugs, medicines, groceries, hardware, nails, and iron. This firm continued in business only about six months, when the death of Mr. Roberts occurred. From this time until 1844, Mr. Willard conducted the business in his own name. He, however, rented the south half of the building, and put in a dry goods stock. In 1844 the firm was changed to that of George Willard & Co., by the admission of S. B. Wells, Esq., a former clerk, as a partner. General produce became a feature of the busiuesss at this time. In the year 1850 the firm was again changed, by the admission of another clerk (Henry Griswold), to Willard, Wells & Co. In 1855, Messrs. Wells and Griswold withdrew. Since this time Mr. Willard has been the sole proprietor. The fine three-story brick block which he now occupies was erected in 1874. The first real estate purchased by Mr. Willard in this township was the lot upon which stands his present business block. This was in the year 1838, and the subsequent year he purchased the property now occupied by William Willard. Mr. George Willard has been engaged in the mercantile business in this city for forty-two years, in addition to five years’ service in the same occupation as clerk. During this time has been quite largely engaged in lake commerce. Had a controlling interest, in whole or in part, in the following vessels, viz., schooners “B. F. Wade,” "Boston,” “Julia Willard,” “York State,” and the bark “Naomi.” Has served as mayor one term, and member of the common council of the “ incorporated village of Ashtabula” for several terms. Has also been township trustee. Has been one of the directors of the Farmers’ National bank from its organization. Was director and president of the Ashtabula County Central plank-road company for a number of years. This road was constructed some time prior to the opening of the Franklin division of the Lake Shore and Michigan Southern railroad, and extended from Ashtabula Harbor to the village of Jefferson, and thence on to the lumber region in Richmond township. This road was for its time a great convenience. Politically, Mr. Willard is ardently Republican.

On the 15th day of September, 1833, he was united in marriage to Julia Francis, daughter of Err W. and Sarah Slawson Mead, who were living at the time in Ashtabula. No children have blest this union. He is a member of the Episcopal church. Mr. Willard served as a member of the vestry and treasurer several years, and as senior warden some twenty years. Thus have we briefly sketched the life of one of Ashtabula’s representative business men. The pioneer in trade, he has grown gray in its prosecution. As a business man, he has been longer in service than any other citizen of Ashtabula. He has ever proven himself a useful and public-spirited citizen. The best interests of his village and of his county and of his church he has always zealously striven to promote. Quiet and unassuming, he is nevertheless an influential citizen, and universally esteemed for his many sterling qualities. The name of George Willard will not be forgotten when in coming years other generations shall be the denizens of this beautiful village.